Why Does Past Charli Look So Much Like Esther F... May 2026

: Early in her career, Charli’s label was sometimes accused of "whitewashing" her heritage, using styling and makeup that leaned into a more generic "indie girl" look.

: They both leaned into a "messy-cool" girl aesthetic, often wearing similar bold makeup and streetwear that made them look like stylistic twins on stage.

Should we look into other or more about Esther Joy’s solo music ? Why does past charli look so much like Esther f...

While they aren't actually the same person, the resemblance during Charli's earlier "Tumblr-era" aesthetics was so striking that it became a running joke and point of confusion within the fanbase. The "Twin" Connection: Esther Joy

The persistent comparison between "past Charli" ( Charli XCX ) and —her former drummer and collaborator—is one of those deep-cut fan theories rooted in more than just a coincidence. : Early in her career, Charli’s label was

Fans often debate how Charli’s look has changed over the years. Some suggest that "past Charli" looked more like Esther because:

Ultimately, the resemblance wasn't just physical; it was a shared subcultural identity that defined a very specific era of pop music. While they aren't actually the same person, the

is a musician and artist who was a key part of Charli XCX’s live band during some of her most iconic early tours. During the Sucker and Vroom Vroom eras, fans frequently pointed out their shared features: