“Part of this show's appeal for me is that even the bad episodes are entertaining, and I thought this was one of those entertainingly bad episodes.” Reddit · r/gameshow · 12 years ago
Community feedback highlights a significant shift in tone. Fans on IMDb and Reddit criticized the inconsistent judging, noting that decisions felt forced to push certain storylines rather than rewarding the best investigators. [S2E7] Whodunnit
Some viewers struggled with "behind-the-scenes" logic that broke the fourth wall. For instance, contestants finding critical evidence in areas they had already searched—but only when the script dictated a "riddle" was ready—ruined the immersion for many. Community Verdict “Part of this show's appeal for me is
This review covers of the reality mystery competition Whodunnit? (broadcast by ABC ), titled "Whodunnit." The Breakdown: A "Messy" Competitive Twist For instance, contestants finding critical evidence in areas