: If you choose not to make a suggested change, provide a clear, evidence-based explanation for why you didn't.
: Always offer specific suggestions on how the authors can improve their work. 2. Responding to Reviews on Your Paper
: List technical errors, typos, or formatting issues in a separate, numbered list for easy reference. My Reviews
: You must respond to every single point raised by each reviewer. Ignoring comments is a common reason for final rejection.
"My Reviews" can refer to a few different types of writing. Below are guides for the three most common interpretations: writing an , responding to reviews you received on your own paper, or writing a literature review paper (a synthesis of existing research) . 1. Writing a Review of a Paper : If you choose not to make a
If you have been asked to peer-review someone else's work, your goal is to provide a constructive and objective evaluation.
If you just received feedback on your own submission (often called "My Reviews"), you need to write a response letter to the editor and reviewers. Responding to Reviews on Your Paper : List
: Clearly state what the paper does well (e.g., novel methodology, clear writing, significant results).